After Harm: Medical Error and the Ethics of Forgiveness by Nancy Berlinger

By Nancy Berlinger

Scientific mistakes is a number one challenge of health and wellbeing care within the usa. every year, extra sufferers die because of clinical errors than are killed by way of motorcar injuries, breast melanoma, or AIDS. whereas such a lot executive and regulatory efforts are directed towards lowering and combating blunders, the activities that are meant to persist with the harm or demise of a sufferer are nonetheless hotly debated. based on Nancy Berlinger, conversations on sufferer safeguard are lacking numerous vital elements: spiritual voices, traditions, and types. In After damage, Berlinger attracts on assets in theology, ethics, faith, and tradition to create a pragmatic and entire method of addressing the wishes of sufferers, households, and clinicians plagued by scientific mistakes. She emphasizes the significance of acknowledging fallibility, telling the reality, confronting emotions of guilt and disgrace, and supplying simply reimbursement. After damage provides very important human dimensions to a subject that has profound outcomes for sufferers and wellbeing and fitness care companies.

Show description

Read or Download After Harm: Medical Error and the Ethics of Forgiveness PDF

Similar administration & policy books

The Human Side of Medicine: Learning What It's Like to Be a Patient and What It's Like to Be a Physician

Savett practiced basic care inner medication for 30 years, and now teaches in regards to the mental and social dimensions of drugs and the doctor-patient courting on the U. of Minnesota clinical college, and at Macalester collage and the U. of St. Thomas. The textual content contains vast excerpts of articles released in a variety of journals, so much some time past decade.

The Business of Plastic Surgery: Navigating a Successful Career

Plastic surgeons battle through wide education to turn into first-class clinicians, yet they generally turn out studying tips on how to perform the enterprise of cosmetic surgery via trial and blunder. This specified e-book, exact particularly to plastic surgeons and different physicians, seeks to handle this obvious oversight and supply advice from profession choice via retirement.

The Right To Be Loved

S. Matthew Liao argues the following that kids have a correct to be enjoyed. to take action he investigates questions similar to no matter if young ones are rightholders; what grounds a kid's correct to cherished; no matter if love is a suitable item of a correct; and different philosophical and useful concerns. His suggestion is that each one people have rights to the elemental stipulations for pursuing a superb lifestyles; consequently, as humans, teenagers have human rights to the elemental stipulations for pursuing an outstanding lifestyles.

The SAGES Manual Ethics of Surgical Innovation

This article presents a entire evaluate of the moral concerns concerned with the improvement, review, and advent of latest remedies of gastrointestinal illnesses. How numerous landmark surgical options have been constructed are defined to teach the demanding situations confronted, and the moral dilemmas those innovators handled.

Additional resources for After Harm: Medical Error and the Ethics of Forgiveness

Sample text

As one physician participating in a focus group on disclosure put it, ‘‘[We are] trying to relieve the soul of some burden when we confess our sins or our errors . . ’’∞≠ Yet Hilfiker does not believe that physicians should attempt to deny or repress the powerful psychological dimensions of harmful mistakes, but rather implores his peers to find ‘‘psychologically healthy’’ ways to ‘‘address [their] own emotional and spiritual experience’’ of such mistakes, and indicts the culture of medicine for offering ‘‘no place for this spiritual healing’’ that physicians desperately need, whether or not they acknowledge this need (Hilfiker 1984, 119, 121).

It appeared in a major American medical journal, where personal narratives candidly describing an author’s own mistakes, as distinct from scholarly articles about or alluding to Physicians’ Narratives 15 mistakes, are still so rare that the word unique may apply to this one. And it describes a mistake made by a physician who is established in his career. Hilfiker was 39 years old when his essay was published, six years after the incident it describes at the beginning of the essay. American physicians do publish accounts of errors they made as students or residents, but it is much less common to find more senior physicians writing about errors that cannot be relegated to inexperience.

Is one of the hardest things I have ever done. Fortunately, their scientific sophistication allows me to describe in some detail what I have done and what my rationale was. But nothing can obscure the hard reality: I have killed their baby. Politely, almost meekly, Russ asks whether the ultrasound examination could not have helped us. It almost seems that he is trying to protect my feelings, trying to absolve me of my responsibility. ’’ (Hilfiker 1984, 119) 16 After Harm Barb and Russ Daily did not file a malpractice suit, even though Hilfiker writes that he is sure they would have won a huge award if they had.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.42 of 5 – based on 26 votes